These brave peace correspondents, reporting from a desperately dangerous place, reveal why U.S. policy is failing in Afghanistan.
For six days in late May, 2010, Emergency, an Italian NGO providing surgery and basic health care in Afghanistan since 1999, welcomed us to visit facilities they operate in the capital city of Kabul and in Panjshir, a neighboring province. We lived with their hospital staff at both places and accompanied them in their weekly trips to various FAPs (First Aid Posts) which the hospitals maintain in small outlying villages.
One morning, accompanying a field officer from the Kabul hospital, we pulled off of the main road and traveled over unpaved lanes, then walked a short distance to a shady grove outside a small Afghan village. Villagers, eager to welcome Emergencyâ€™s staff and drivers, served ripe mulberries and a salty cucumber yogurt drink. We sat in a circle, shaded by the trees. When breezes stirred the branches, weâ€™d enjoy a momentary rain of mulberries, much to the amusement of little children nearby.
The five youngsters, age five Â ten, smiled shyly at us, shook our hands, and then joined their older brother to systematically gather mulberries. Using a large hoe, the older brother slammed the tree trunk. The children caught the cascading mulberries in a plastic tarp. Then they sorted the fruits, seeming to take discipline and routine for granted.
Earlier, Felippo, an Emergency nurse in Panjshir, had told us about how hard life can be for Afghan children in rural areas. â€œThey never get a day off,â€ exclaimed Felippo. â€œNever. If they attend school, and school is closed for a day, the kids join workers in the fields.â€ Felippo, who has been to Afghanistan for three six month rotations, fantasizes about building a theme park where kids could play and be entertained.
The majority of Afghanistanâ€™s agricultural laborers, both children and adults, face harsh realities.
Many villagers have little access to health care or education. Diseases such as pneumonia, gastroenteritis, malaria, and malnourishment contribute toward the deaths of 850 Afghan children every day.
High Child Mortality
In rural areas, a family typically has 10 Â 15 children. Not all are expected to survive. When a child is born, a ceremony to name the infant takes place several months later because the childâ€™s survival of the first months of life is a cause for great relief and celebration.
Felippoâ€™s supervisor, Micha, the Medical Director at the Panjshir Hospital, explains that malnutrition is a social problem. â€œMothers arenâ€™t instructed about nutrition,â€ she says. â€œSometimes in large families, the four year old is in charge of the one year old. Or the mother doesnâ€™t breast feed during the first month, – the most crucial month. If fraternal twins are born, the boy will be breast fed, but not the girl.â€
â€œThey donâ€™t come to the hospital when symptoms of sickness appear,â€ Micha continues. â€œThey wait till a child is near death. Malnutrition is difficult to manage. Children will become healthy, but the malnourishment recurs; itâ€™s often fatal.â€
â€œPoor hygiene is another serious problem, especially if families canâ€™t provide clean water,â€ Micha pointed out, â€œand, you see, this is also related to poverty. Sometimes the children drink unclean water, causing gastroenteritis.â€
Intent on helping solve these basic problems, Emergency workers use the FAPs to educate people about nutrition and basic hygiene. In winter months, the roads often become impassable. In some places, Felippo hikes for two hours beyond the point where a vehicle canâ€™t continue, carrying medicine and supplies in his backpack.
â€œCan you imagine,â€ asked Felippo, â€œthat last year, when I finished my term of service, in January, when it was my last visit to a First Aid Post that is furthest from our hospital, people walked four hours in the snow to say goodbye to me. Yes, I fell in love.â€
Combining Health Care and Nonviolence
It isnâ€™t hard to imagine why the staff feels so loyal to Emergencyâ€™s patients and to the organizationâ€™s goals.
Emergency is treating war victims as patients, and wonâ€™t allow police or military to enter the hospital, carrying weapons. Circumstances that occasion an injury or a wound never determine whether or not the patient will be admitted. While neutral as regards offering medical treatment, Emergency has been clearly partisan in itâ€™s rejection of all wars. Their literature and outreach clarifies that the most important preventive measure to safeguard against war related wounds and injuries is the abolition of weapons.
In a pediatric ward at the Emergency hospital in Kabul, doctors and nurses tend youngsters who’ve mainly been hurt by landmines. Sometimes the boys go outside and sit on the grass with older fellows. Many share in common the experience of having lost limbs or fingers or toes to land mine or remote controlled explosions.
Young Victims of War
One afternoon, we sat in the hospital garden listening to the director of an Afghanistan human rights NGO talk about plans for President Hamid Karzai’s peace jirga, scheduled to begin on June 2nd, in a tent outside of Kabul. 1600 people are expected to attend. We watched boys and young men assemble in a circle, all wearing thin hospital gowns, most with bandaged limbs and some having suffered amputations. They were each from different regions and likely held quite divergent views….a jirga of sorts.
Esmatullah, 7 years old, came to the hospital a month ago because of a mine injury. He is from the Paktika province. â€œHe has never cried, not once,â€ said Anil, the hospitalâ€™s physical therapist. â€œNot while dressings were being changed, not during physical therapy. Heâ€™s a real Pashtun.â€ Esmatullah beamed when Anil patted him on the head.
Anidullah , age 11, suffered a bullet injury. He was studying inside the mosque, in his town in the Ghazni province, when a battle erupted between U.S. and Taliban fighters. He doesnâ€™t know which side hit him.
Nur Said, a teenager, lost one eye and has only one finger on his right hand. He is learning to feed himself. An unexploded device exploded when he picked it up. Sometimes the children try to open up the unexploded devices and take out the brass so that they can sell it.
A young man, age 21, was injured when he was a driver for U.S. forces. He said that the U.S. convoys have GPS systems for the front car and the back car, in each convoy. He was driving a Land Cruiser, in the middle of a U.S. military convoy, without benefit of a GPS.
â€œI could tell a lot of stories,â€ he says. â€œSome people were killed for no reason.â€
After he was injured, the U.S. forces brought him by helicopter to Emergencyâ€™s hospital in Lashkar Gah, where treatment, as in all Emergency facilities, is free of charge. Emergency staff then brought him to Kabul for surgery. The U.S. hasnâ€™t offered this young man any compensation or assistance for future rehabilitation. Heâ€™s anxious not to talk more about his case for fear of being harmed.
But, asked what he would do if U.S. forces attacked his family, he said he would fight. â€œI would react against them if they killed my family. If I lose my family, I donâ€™t want the life.â€
More Compassionate Choices Need to be Made
Unlike ourselves on this visit, the Emergency staff doesnâ€™t ask many questions about what brought patients to their hospital. Their all-consuming task is to help them leave, healed, and, as much as possible, physically rehabilitated.
Still, they canâ€™t help but feel frustrations over problems that could be solved if the westerners whoâ€™ve come to Afghanistan would establish priorities more sympathetic to human needs.
â€œThe price of fuel for one of the U.S. warplanes roaring overhead, on a routine flight between Bagram and Kabul, could allow many creative choices if it were made available to an Afghan village,â€ said Mr. Noor Akbari, an analyst working for the Ministry of Agriculture. â€œVillagers could build a health center, buy a communally owned pump, get assistance to spray the trees, hire a midwife, or organize agronomy training and literacy programs.â€
Anil suggests that the concrete used for protective blocks surrounding U.S. bases and checkpoints could build as many as ten dams to provide electricity for people.
Felippo notes that the Italian government spends one million dollars, every day, to maintain Italyâ€™s military presence in Afghanistan. â€œWhat could we do with just one day of their funds!?â€ asks Felippo. â€œWe could build another hospital.â€
As the eight year long war drags on, claiming more victims every day, the U.S. develops increasingly sophisticated means of surveillance, laser guided bombing, and robotized weapon usage. Meanwhile, Taliban bomb makers develop their expertise and teach new recruits to make and plant explosives. â€œIn 2007 there were 2,600 attacks, in Afghanistan, using homemade bombs. In January alone, in 2010, there were 1,000 bomb attacks,â€ according to a May 30th report in The Sunday Times. â€œOver the past three years the US military has pumped more than Â£10 billion into research and technology designed to detect and neutralise the IEDs, (Improvised Explosive Devices) that cost the Taliban just Â£20 to make.â€
If we want Afghans to reject the Taliban’s brand of weapon development and attacks, we in the U.S. need to show our own determination to foster the works of mercy rather than the works of war. The Emergency hospital staff, unarmed and courageous, provide a fine example.Â Î¦